Spanish-American
Institute
Institutional
Effectiveness Plan Program Development Addendum
Fall 2012
Program Development, Planning and Review
Standard 1: The program or language
institution has a plan, in writing, for development of the program or language
institution, including planning, implementation, and evaluation.
Rationale for appears to partially meet:
SAI has a 5-year Institutional Effectiveness Plan as required by the ACICS accrediting agency. As an Institutional Effectiveness Plan, it is well written and complete and calls for periodic review of program components. While the Institutional Effectiveness Plan will be reviewed every five years, definite time frames for planning for program development are not included. Generally, only the dates of the last completed review are given. For example, the Institutional Effectiveness Plan states, “Assess future infrastructure needs and plan for improvement.” However, there is no date indicating when the review took place and when it will happen again.
In
addition, the discussion for this standard
states, “the written plan must include the tasks, process, responsible
parties, and time lines, as well as a list of the documentation that provides
evidence that the plan has been implemented.” Although Say’s Institutional
Effectiveness Plan includes tasks for evaluating the human, financial, and
physical resources needed to reach its goals, it does not describe how those
tasks will be accomplished.
Comment: Spanish-American Institute’s five year Institutional Effectiveness Plan has been revised to include “tasks, process, responsible parties, and time lines, as well as a list of the documentation that provides evidence that the plan has been implemented.” We have added more specific time frames and more detail on the process. This format will be used as part of the next five year IEP.
Refer to the updated IEP in the Addendum.
No. |
Tasks |
Process |
Responsible |
Timeline /
Documentation |
|
Current Status |
Next Review Period |
||||
1.1 |
Keep ESL teaching materials current |
Dean
and English Chair reviewed NorthStar 3rd ed. with the NorthStar
representatives Decision
made to continue with 2nd ed. as long as possible. Faculty
orientation to new edition ARW
3rd ed. phase-in 1/2010 and ESL 2 phase-in in 10/2010 |
President, Dean of Academic Affairs and English Chairs |
Summer 2009 Faculty Meeting Completed December 2011 Meeting Minute |
December 2013 |
1.2 |
Review
and update ESL syllabi |
Task
performed every two years by Student Achievement Standards Committee |
Dean of Academic Affairs |
Review began Summer 2011 |
Fall 2013 |
1.3 |
Obtain
renewal of approval for current ESL courses and programs from NYS State
Department of Education (SED). |
President
and DAA complete SED application for renewal |
President and Dean of Academic Affairs |
Received SED renewal in 2010 |
|
1.4 |
Consider
new English courses or course revisions |
Part
of Faculty Meeting agenda |
Dean of Academic Affairs DAA, English Chair and faculty |
Meeting Minute |
|
1.5 |
Add
English Literacy course option to the curriculum for pre-literate students in
response to need |
Recommendation
from ESL 1 teachers |
President, Dean of Academic Affairs DAA, English Chair and ESL faculty |
Submitted for approval |
|
1.6 |
Add
a Pre-GED course to accommodate students not ready for regular GED
instruction |
New
605 “Pre-GED Foundation for GED Preparation prepared and presented to SED |
President and Dean of Academic Affairs |
Proposed in Fall 2010 |
|
1.7 |
To
assure the integration of the four language skills and their measurement in
English courses through standards based measureable objectives and criterion
referenced testing in all courses |
IEL Chairs appointed. Current syllabi and course
test reviews begun for ·
standards- based measureable objectives keyed to acquisition of
English language outcomes and ·
criterion referenced testing of standards-based English language skills |
Dean of Academic Affairs, Intensive English Language (IEL) Division Chairs, English faculty |
August 2011 |
|
1.8 |
Apply
for Commission on English Language Program Accreditation (CEA). |
CEA
application approved. |
All personnel |
July 2011 |
|
No. |
Tasks |
Process |
Responsible |
Timeline /
Documentation |
|
Current Status |
Next Review Period |
||||
2.1 |
Update
keyboarding and computer application course textbooks, and software, as
needed. Review and update syllabi as
needed. |
Determine
career courses using the most recent editions of course textbooks. Purchase
30 site licenses for QuickBooks, installed on nine iMacs in the Accounting
Room Purchase
and install Mavis Beacon Teaches Typing
software |
Dean of Academic Affairs and Career Program faculty |
Spring 2009 (Review texts) August 2009 (QuickBooks) September 2009 All reviewed in 2011 |
September 2011 |
2.2 |
Obtain
State Department of Education (SED) career program and course renewal in
2010. |
Determined
by SED renewal notification 960
Access & 965 PowerPoint |
President
and Dean of
Academic Affairs |
Submitted for review |
|
2.3 |
To
introduce new courses in response to changing technology, workplace needs,
and/or student interest |
Prepared and submitted application for approval on
three MAC courses |
President, Dean of Academic Affairs and faculty |
Submitted to SED and approved Winter 2011 |
Upon SED notification |
2.4 |
To
assure the integration of the four language skills and their measurement in
non-ESL courses |
Review current syllabi and course tests for ·
measurable objectives keyed to acquisition of English language
outcome and ·
criterion referenced testing of English language skills |
Dean of Academic Affairs, IEL (Intensive English Language) Chair and
non-ESL faculty |
Begin date, August 2011 End date, November 2011 |
August 2013 |
No. |
Tasks |
Process |
Responsible |
Timeline /
Documentation |
|
Current Status |
Next Review Period |
||||
3.1.a |
Expand
the Institute Library collection |
Request
recommendations from faculty |
Dean of Academic Affairs |
|
|
3.1.b |
Disseminate
information about Institute Library
updates to faculty and staff |
Faculty
Meetings |
Dean of Academic Affairs |
|
|
3.1.c |
Track
student usage of Library through Library
sign-in sheets and print check-out (circulation records). Use data to determine if more faculty
development needed on library integration |
Library
sign-in log and automated book checkout track individual student use of
library resources |
Dean of Academic Affairs |
|
|
3.1.d |
Review
and revise Library homepage, as needed |
Suggestions
from DAA, |
President |
No new requests |
|
3.1.e |
Develop
bibliography correlated to NS 2nd and 3rd ed. |
Intermediate
and above texts and thematic material and add to the Library collection |
Dean of Academic Affairs and ESL faculty |
Correlated bibliography created Fall 2009 December 2010 & |
|
3.1.f |
Provide
computers for student use in Library |
Nine
iMacs installed in Library replacing five older PCs |
President |
Installed October 2010 |
Software updated every quarter |
No. |
Tasks |
Process |
Responsible |
Timeline /
Documentation |
|
Current Status |
Next Review Period |
||||
3.2.a |
Encourage
faculty integration of library research and information literacy in
curriculum correlated to textbook activities |
Memos
to faculty about information literacy course objectives in textbooks and
syllabi Institute
Instructional Resources Manual contains sections on the Institute
Library, public library access, and information literacy skills development Institute
bulletin boards contain posting about applying for library cards and
libraries nearest the Institute |
Dean of Academic Affairs and faculty |
Faculty meeting agenda Manual and bulletin board prepared October 2009 Instructional
Resource Manual |
Brought to attention of new faculty and students as part of orientation
process Bulletin boards updated when new information on public library becomes
available |
3.2.b |
Institute
the NorthStar Bibliography with print material related to NorthStar unit
themes and topic |
With
faculty input, expanded the Spanish-American Institute Library collection
with print material including but not limited to gender concepts and roles,
parenting, poverty amelioration, emotional intelligence, and the environment NorthStar
Bibliography project resulted in addition of c. 40 books on themes related to
questions of role of biology or culture in forming gender concepts and roles |
Dean of Academic Affairs and faculty |
Winter 2010 |
|
No. |
Tasks |
Process |
Responsible |
Timeline /
Documentation |
|
Current Status |
Next Review Period |
||||
3.3 |
Review,
revise (if needed), distribute, and monitor
Institute’s “Fair Use” Guidelines for Duplication of Copyrighted
Material |
Institute copyright policy and practice reaffirmed
in ·
faculty/staff meetings, ·
memos, and ·
Instructional Resource Manual |
President and Dean of Academic Affairs |
Instructional
Resource Manual |
|
No. |
Tasks |
Process |
Responsible |
Timeline /
Documentation |
|
Current Status |
Next Review Period |
||||
4.1 |
Keep
audio and visual instructional support material current and easily accessible
to faculty |
Growth in instructional support material holdings
evident from: q Institute Library
automated catalog and q “ESL Video and Audio Tape Titles
and Call Numbers” and “Teacher’s Manuals and Call Numbers” sections of Instructional Resources Manual |
Dean of Academic Affairs |
Instructional
Resource Manual |
|
4.2 |
Provide
faculty with access to textbook teacher’s manuals, teaching guides, and A-V
material (where available) |
Faculty
may checkout companion textbook, A-V material, and teacher’s manuals as well
as teacher’s guides through the
Bookstore. Memos inform them of
updates and additions |
Dean of Academic Affairs |
Available Winter 2011 |
Updated as new materials are purchased |
4.3 |
Provide
faculty and staff access to updated Instructional
Resource Manuals |
Instructional Resource
Manual
revised and divided into two sections in late 2009: Primary
Materials and Miscellaneous
Materials (older collection). Primary Materials updated frequently
and contains expanded sections on public library access and on Institute
Library collection correlated to NorthStar textbook units |
Dean of Academic Affairs |
Available Winter 2011 |
Updated as new materials are purchased |
4.4 |
Provide
information about and access to MyNorthStar Lab, the on-line instructional
support site for NorthStar 3rd ed. with 3rd ed.
phase-in in 2010 |
Dean
of Academic Affairs reviewed NS 3e MyNorthStar Lab Access
obtained for ESL faculty; however, faculty consensus that MyNorthStarLab of
limited utility compared to still available older NS online support |
Dean of Academic Affairs and ESL faculty |
Spring/Summer 2010 Reviewed again Winter 2011 |
Ongoing implementation of registering students as they enroll each
month |
4.5 |
Develop
faculty capacity to use on-line instructional materials in the classroom,
especially ESL material correlated to textbooks |
Purchased
2 iMAC computers with 27” screens for classroom use with online, flash drive,
DVD, and CD playback capacity. Faculty
meeting report from faculty using online material in classroom. Faculty
workshop included NorthStar online support material |
President, Dean of Academic Affairs, faculty |
Installed June 2010 Faculty Meeting Meeting
Minutes |
|
No. |
Tasks |
Process |
Responsible |
Timeline /
Documentation |
|
Current Status |
Next Review Period |
||||
5.1 |
Inventory
computer and other hardware, periodically |
Determined
by need, e.g., in preparation of accreditation visits by SED, ACICS and CEA |
President |
January 2012 |
January 2014 |
5.2 |
Upgrade
school connectivity to mission critical industrial strength reliability. Assure fail-safe mechanisms, including
double Internet access and backup proxy server. Improve wireless connectivity throughout
the school. Create wireless
redundancies to enlarge number of simultaneous wireless connections used by
faculty, staff, and students. Install.
battery backup for office and classroom computers |
Base
upon consultant analysis and recommendations installed HP
ProReliant ML150G6 Unixproxy server to backup website, e-mail, and firewall
gateway with built-in redundancies and triple power supplies Apple
Airport Extreme wireless hubs to support 250 connections DSL2
line to increase bandwidth bandwidth to download speeds of up to 15
megs/second. Splitter box installed
for fail-safe switching to T-1 connection if DSL goes down Conversion
from 10-yr. old analog to digital T-1 telephony |
President |
Server - Spring 2010 Airport – October 2010 DSL2 – July 2011 Phone System – Summer 2011 |
Internal review - External consultant review - |
5.3 |
Renew,
replace, upgrade, or obtain
instructional hardware and software Provide
permanent audio playback capabilities in all classrooms by 2011 |
Based
upon recommendations of DAA and faculty Hardware Upgrades +/-25
CD players with iPod and computer connectivity provided in each ESL classroom Added
3 additional replacement CD playback units Purchased
three Insignia 26” flat screen HD-DVD all-in-ones for ESL course support Purchased
two iMAC computers with 27” screens Ricoh
Aficio color laser printer installed in Computer Room Software Mavis Beacon Teaches
Typing for
MAC 25
QuickBooks for MAC site licenses |
President |
Hardware Computer upgrade phased between 2009 and 2011 CD players available December 2010 Insignia – October 2009 27” iMACs – June 2010 Ricoh printer Spring 2009 Software Mavis Beacon Adobe CS4 - Spring 2009 |
Hardware repaired and replaced as required Replace as required |
5.4 |
Assess
future infrastructure needs and plan for improvement |
External
assessment by computer consultant to identify current or potential computer infrastructure
obsolescence especially as it affects school database system and record
preservation |
President |
February 2011 |
February 2016 |
No. |
Tasks |
Process |
Responsible |
Timeline /
Documentation |
|
Current Status |
Next Review Period |
||||
6.1 |
Plan,
schedule, and implement faculty/staff development workshops with faculty and
staff input |
Faculty Workshop topics 2010 2011 2012 |
Dean of Academic Affairs, Program Chairs and faculty |
May 8, 2010 December 10, 2010 September 10, 2011 December 3, 2011 February 4, 2012 June 16, 2012 Meeting Minutes |
Next Faculty Meeting - |
6.2 |
Assure
communication through print and on-line distribution of faculty and staff meetings and workshop minutes. Maintain “Faculty Matters” section on
school homepage with links to
documents relevant to faculty
and academic affairs (e.g., Handbooks, Syllabi, IEP, etc.) |
Meeting
minutes routinely distributed to all faculty and staff. and archived on-line
since 10/07 “Faculty
Matters” menu created on school website 10/07 and updated periodically |
President
and Dean of
Academic Affairs
|
Meeting Minute Faculty Matters |
As required |
6.3 |
Update
and distribute curriculum implementation guidelines and strategies to English
and program faculty |
Language Skills in
Computer Education manual developed 10/09 ESL Teacher Orientation: Standards of Good Practice in ESL manual
for faculty created in 2008 and updated periodically DAA
meets with new faculty individually to review Institute curriculum guidelines |
Dean of Academic Affairs |
Language Skills in
Computer Education ESL Teacher Orientation: Standards of Good Practice in ESL |
Fall 2014 |
6.4 |
Administer in-class “Student Evaluation of
Faculty” form and convey results to
individual faculty |
Survey
administered by President DAA
complies data and communicates to faculty |
President
and Dean of
Academic Affairs
|
|
|
6.5 |
Conduct
individual annual professional development conferences that include review of
instruction |
Annual
individual review |
Dean of Academic Affairs |
Spring 2012 |
Spring 2012 |
6.6 |
Maintain
database about new and emerging graduate TEFL and other programs for interested
faculty and staff. Advise interested
faculty and staff about available graduate programs. Write letters of recommendation upon
request |
After
consultation with Dean of Academic Affairs: · One faculty student
associate completed Touro College MSIS program · One faculty member
enrolled in Touro College MSIS program · One faculty member
referred to and enrolled in Touro College TEFL program |
Dean of Academic Affairs |
Summer and Fall of 2009 |
|
6.7 |
Establish
faculty and staff computer purchase program through payroll reduction |
Fifteen
dollars deducted each pay period |
President |
MAC laptops available for purchase as of February 2010 |
Program is ongoing |
No. |
Tasks |
Process |
Responsible |
Timeline /
Documentation |
|
Current Status |
Next Review Period |
||||
7.1 |
Administer
an ESL placement test upon admissions |
Faculty
Student Services Associates administer
and record results on individual student records Accreditation
Self-Study Student Achievement Standards Committee reviews placement and
academic progress testing |
Faculty Student Services Associates |
Alternative
ESL placement and academic progress processes under review by the
Accreditation Self-Study Student Achievement
Standard Committee starting early Fall, 2011 with recommendations
expected in early 2012 Placement
test replaced with CELSA (Combined English Language
Skills Assessment) Recent
analysis of Level 2 ESL indicates accuracy of placement of students |
CELSA results and placement continue to analyzed First review by Student Achievement committee |
7.2 |
Administer
nationally-normed standardized externally developed SLEP test to assess ESL
student placement and progress. Review
alternative testing instruments and processes to assess student placement and
progress |
Faculty Student
Services Associates administer and
record results on individual student records DAA analyzes and
reports aggregate results. Student Services staff enter on student record DDA
review confirms conclusions in her analysis of 2004-2007 data indicating: ·
accurate
initial student course placement in most
instances ·
aggregate test
scores per ESL 3 levels and above increased from 2006 forward over previous
years consistent with anticipated improved academic outcomes because of
implementation of new ESL curriculum goals and instructional emphases ·
SLEP data still
found most useful for individual student guidance and for aggregate
assessment in ESL 3-6 and BE ·
SLEP student
scores for ESL 1-2 scores consistently too low and ARW/TOEFL scores too high
to yield useful information about individual student placement or progress or
course assessment |
Faculty Student Services Associates and Dean of Academic Affairs |
Placement
test replaced with CELSA (Combined English Language
Skills Assessment) Recent
analysis of Level 2 ESL indicates accuracy of placement of students |
CELSA results and placement continue to analyzed First review Student Achievement committee |
7.3 |
Develop
formal test monitoring system to assure that tests are criterion referenced
and meet standards of good practice reflected in stated measurable objectives
for all ESL and non-ESL courses |
Dean
of Academic Affairs’ periodic review of in-class test materials indicated
that most ESL faculty using only
WorldView and NorthStar companion test materials Accreditation
Self-Study Student Achievement Standards Committee recommendation led to
formal test duplication test request form developed to facilitate test
monitoring and to create data-base validating that faculty testing in
accordance with standards of good practice, including integration of four
language skills in all ESL and non-ESL classes |
Dean of Academic Affairs, IEL Chairs and faculty |
Recommended
Spring 2011 |
Process reviewed |
No. |
Tasks |
Process |
Responsible |
Timeline /
Documentation |
|
Current Status |
Next Review Period |
||||
8.1 |
Institute
review process for exams to assure that career course exams require
demonstration of English language skills, critical thinking, and other
standards of good practice consistent with stated and measurable course
objective |
Dean
of Academic Affairs’ periodic review of in-class test materials indicated
wide differences in testing standards in bi-monthly teacher generated exams Student
Achievement Standards Committee recommendation led to formal test duplication
test request form developed to facilitate test monitoring and to create
data-base validating that faculty testing in accordance with standards of
good practice consistent with course objectives |
Dean of Academic Affairs and IEL Chairs |
Implemented
Fall 2011 |
Process reviewed |
No. |
Tasks |
Process |
Responsible |
Timeline /
Documentation |
|
Current Status |
Next Review Period |
||||
8.1 |
Create off-site
document and database backup |
Backup individual files
throughout day and financial and academic databases at night |
President and Deans |
Backup
process created Summer 2010 |
Reviewed daily to ensure access is available |
Program Development, Planning and Review
Standard 2: The program or language
institution regularly reviews and revises its program components and has a
plan, in writing, to guide the review of curricular elements, student
assessment practices, and student services policies and activities. The plan is
systematically implemented.
Rationale for appears to partially meet:
SAI has a 5-year Institutional Effectiveness Plan as required by ACICS. As an Institutional Effectiveness Plan, it is well written and complete and calls for periodic review of program components. While the Institutional Effectiveness Plan will be reviewed every five years, definite time frames for the next assessment of a given component are not clear. Generally, only the dates of the last completed review are given. For example, the Institutional Effectiveness Plan states, “Review and update ESL syllabi periodically but at least once every two years” and indicates that this was completed. However, there is no date indicating when the review took place and when it will happen again.
In addition, the discussion for this standard states, “the written plan must include the tasks, process, responsible parties, time lines as well as the documentation that provides evidence that the plan has been implemented. The SAI’s Institutional Effectiveness Plan does not describe the process for review, i.e., how the review will be done.
Other comments:
A calendar giving specific dates for the review of program components would benefit the program.
Comments: Spanish-American Institute’s five year Institutional Effectiveness Plan has been revised to include “tasks, process, responsible parties, and time lines, as well as a list of the documentation that provides evidence that the plan has been implemented.” An example of the updated IEP is found with Program Development, Planning and Review: Standard 1.
The following workshops are planned for each of the next four Faculty Meetings:
§ December 15, 2012 “Selecting a Process to Improve Our Pronunciation”
§ April 20, 2013 “Orientation – Incorporating the Program into the Curriculum"
§ August 17, 2013 "Using Rubrics to Assess Students’ Speaking and Writing Skills”
§ December 21, 2013 "Reviewing the Exit Exams on MyEnglisLab as an Assessment Tool”